The Forge Shop

The Store

Magic: The Gathering — 8,732 in stock · same-day store pickup

8,679 items

1 in stockPair o' Dice Lost - Foil
Pair o' Dice Lost - Foil
Unfinity · ✦ Foil NM
$0.32
1 in stockPalace Jailer
Palace Jailer
Mystery Booster NM
$0.25
5 in stockPalace Siege
Palace Siege
Fate Reforged NM
$0.79
4 in stockPaladin Class
Paladin Class
Adventures in the Forgotten Realms NM
$0.42
1 in stockPaladin en-Vec
Paladin en-Vec
Exodus NM
$0.67
4 in stockPaladin's Arms
Paladin's Arms
Final Fantasy NM
$0.25
2 in stockPalantir of Orthanc (Borderless)
Palantir of Orthanc (Borderless)
The Hobbit Eternal NM Borderless
$21.30
2 in stockPalladium Myr
Palladium Myr
Wizards Play Network 2025 NM Retro Frame
$0.41
1 in stockPandemonium
Pandemonium
Exodus NM
$7.08
3 in stockPanharmonicon
Panharmonicon
Kaladesh LP
$6.78
1 in stockPantlaza, Sun-Favored - Extended Art
Pantlaza, Sun-Favored - Extended Art
The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander NM Extended Art
$7.36
1 in stockParadise Plume - Foil
Paradise Plume - Foil
Time Spiral · ✦ Foil LP
$3.06
2 in stockParadox Engine
Paradox Engine
Aether Revolt NM
$6.48
1 in stockParallel Evolution
Parallel Evolution
Torment LP
$6.38
1 in stockParallel Lives
Parallel Lives
Innistrad NM
$38.38
1 in stockParallel Lives
Parallel Lives
Innistrad LP
$37.61
2 in stockParalyze
Paralyze
Unlimited NM
$2.71
1 in stockParasitic Impetus - Foil
Parasitic Impetus - Foil
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · ✦ Foil NM
$0.38
2 in stockParhelion II
Parhelion II
Commander: Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty NM
$0.86
2 in stockParhelion II
Parhelion II
War Of The Spark NM
$0.88
1 in stockPark Re-Entry - Foil
Park Re-Entry - Foil
Unfinity · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockParker Luck
Parker Luck
Marvel's Spider-Man NM
$0.27
1 in stockParker Luck - Extended Art
Parker Luck - Extended Art
Marvel's Spider-Man NM Extended Art
$0.35
1 in stockParker Luck - Foil - Extended Art
Parker Luck - Foil - Extended Art
Marvel's Spider-Man · ✦ Foil NM Extended Art
$0.41
1 in stockPart in Friendship
Part in Friendship
The Hobbit · ✦ Foil NM Extended Art
$0.54
2 in stockPart the Waterveil
Part the Waterveil
Battle for Zendikar LP
$0.90
3 in stockPart the Waterveil
Part the Waterveil
Battle for Zendikar NM
$0.92
2 in stockPart Water
Part Water
Legends NM
$6.50
1 in stockPassionate Archaeologist - Foil
Passionate Archaeologist - Foil
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · ✦ Foil NM
$16.16
1 in stockPatchwork Crawler
Patchwork Crawler
Innistrad: Crimson Vow NM
$0.25
1 in stockPatchwork Crawler
Patchwork Crawler
Innistrad: Crimson Vow MP
$0.25
4 in stockPatchwork Crawler
Patchwork Crawler
Innistrad: Crimson Vow LP
$0.25
1 in stockPath of Ancestry - Foil
Path of Ancestry - Foil
Commander Legends · ✦ Foil NM
$0.40
1 in stockPath of Ancestry - Foil
Path of Ancestry - Foil
Fallout · ✦ Foil NM
$0.68
1 in stockPath of Discovery
Path of Discovery
Bloomburrow Commander NM
$0.26
1 in stockPath of the Enigma
Path of the Enigma
March of the Machine Commander NM
$0.30
3 in stockPatient Rebuilding
Patient Rebuilding
Core Set 2019 NM
$0.58
1 in stockPatrician Geist
Patrician Geist
Innistrad: Midnight Hunt LP
$0.35
2 in stockPatrician Geist
Patrician Geist
Innistrad: Midnight Hunt NM
$0.36
1 in stockPatrician Geist - Extended Art
Patrician Geist - Extended Art
Innistrad: Midnight Hunt NM Extended Art
$0.39
1 in stockPatrician Geist - Foil - Promo Pack
Patrician Geist - Foil - Promo Pack
Promo Pack: Innistrad: Midnight Hunt · ✦ Foil NM Promo Pack
$0.43
1 in stockPatron of the Orochi
Patron of the Orochi
Betrayers of Kamigawa LP
$11.36
4 in stockPavel Maliki
Pavel Maliki
Legends NM
$1.77
2 in stockPeacewalker Colossus
Peacewalker Colossus
Aether Revolt NM
$0.35
3 in stockPearl Lake Ancient
Pearl Lake Ancient
Khans of Tarkir LP
$0.46
2 in stockPearled Unicorn
Pearled Unicorn
Unlimited NM
$0.75
1 in stockPedal to the Metal - Foil
Pedal to the Metal - Foil
Aetherdrift · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockPeer into the Abyss
Peer into the Abyss
Core Set 2021 DMG
$2.35
4 in stockPelt Collector
Pelt Collector
Guilds of Ravnica LP
$0.37
1 in stockPendelhaven - Foil
Pendelhaven - Foil
Timeshifted · ✦ Foil NM
$19.97
1 in stockPentad Prism
Pentad Prism
Double Masters NM
$0.32
1 in stockPentarch Paladin
Pentarch Paladin
Time Spiral NM
$0.46
1 in stockPentavus
Pentavus
Duel Decks: Elspeth vs. Tezzeret NM
$0.25
2 in stockPentavus
Pentavus
Magic 2012 NM
$0.25
1 in stockPenumbra Umbra
Penumbra Umbra
Mystery Booster 2 NM
$0.25
4 in stockPerennial Behemoth
Perennial Behemoth
The Brothers' War NM
$0.49
1 in stockPerilous Landscape
Perilous Landscape
Modern Horizons 3 NM
$0.25
1 in stockPerilous Myr - Foil
Perilous Myr - Foil
Commander Legends · ✦ Foil NM
$0.28
1 in stockPerilous Snare
Perilous Snare
Aetherdrift NM
$0.33
1 in stockPerilous Vault
Perilous Vault
Commander Masters NM
$0.34