The Forge Shop

The Store

Magic: The Gathering — 8,732 in stock · same-day store pickup

8,679 items

1 in stockPredict
Predict
Commander 2018 NM
$1.39
4 in stockPreeminent Captain
Preeminent Captain
Magic 2015 LP
$0.73
1 in stockPrehistoric Pet
Prehistoric Pet
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles NM
$0.26
1 in stockPrehistoric Pet - Foil
Prehistoric Pet - Foil
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles NM
$0.26
3 in stockPress the Enemy
Press the Enemy
The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth NM
$0.61
3 in stockPride Sovereign
Pride Sovereign
Hour of Devastation NM
$5.01
1 in stockPriest of Ancient Lore
Priest of Ancient Lore
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate NM
$0.36
1 in stockPriest of Forgotten Gods
Priest of Forgotten Gods
Ravnica Allegiance NM
$1.06
2 in stockPriest of the Blood Rite
Priest of the Blood Rite
Magic Origins LP
$0.25
1 in stockPriest of the Crossing
Priest of the Crossing
Aetherdrift Commander NM Extended Art
$0.25
1 in stockPriest of the Crossing - Extended Art
Priest of the Crossing - Extended Art
Aetherdrift Commander NM Extended Art
$0.25
1 in stockPrimal Boost
Primal Boost
Dominaria Remastered NM
$0.25
1 in stockPrimal Clay
Primal Clay
Antiquities MP
$3.14
1 in stockPrimal Command
Primal Command
Lorwyn MP
$0.77
1 in stockPrimal Command
Primal Command
Lorwyn LP
$0.86
1 in stockPrimal Command
Primal Command
Strixhaven: Mystical Archives NM
$1.55
1 in stockPrimal Might
Primal Might
Outlaws of Thunder Junction: Breaking News NM
$0.26
3 in stockPrimal Prayers
Primal Prayers
Modern Horizons 3 NM
$0.27
1 in stockPrimal Prayers - Borderless
Primal Prayers - Borderless
Modern Horizons 3 NM Borderless
$0.43
1 in stockPrimal Surge
Primal Surge
Avacyn Restored NM
$5.37
1 in stockPrimal Vigor
Primal Vigor
Commander 2013 LP
$14.03
2 in stockPrimary Research
Primary Research
Secrets of Strixhaven NM
$0.25
1 in stockPrimeval Titan
Primeval Titan
Iconic Masters NM
$6.46
1 in stockPrimeval Titan
Primeval Titan
Magic 2011 LP
$10.48
1 in stockPrimeval Titan
Primeval Titan
Magic 2012 NM
$7.78
1 in stockPrimordial Hydra
Primordial Hydra
Magic 2013 LP
$7.67
11 in stockPrishe's Wanderings
Prishe's Wanderings
Final Fantasy NM
$0.25
4 in stockPrism Array
Prism Array
Battle for Zendikar LP
$0.25
1 in stockPrismatic Geoscope - The List
Prismatic Geoscope - The List
The List NM The List
$1.89
1 in stockPrismatic Lens - Foil
Prismatic Lens - Foil
Time Spiral Remastered · ✦ Foil NM
$1.12
1 in stockPrison Sentence - Foil
Prison Sentence - Foil
The Brothers' War · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockPrize Pig
Prize Pig
Commander: The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth NM
$0.37
1 in stockProclamation of Rebirth
Proclamation of Rebirth
Dissension NM
$0.63
1 in stockProcrastinate
Procrastinate
Secrets of Strixhaven NM
$0.25
1 in stockProctor's Gaze
Proctor's Gaze
Secrets of Strixhaven NM
$0.25
1 in stockProdigal Sorcerer
Prodigal Sorcerer
Unlimited NM
$1.53
4 in stockProfane Command
Profane Command
Modern Masters 2015 MP
$0.33
4 in stockProfaner of the Dead
Profaner of the Dead
Dragons of Tarkir LP
$0.32
1 in stockProfessional Wrestler
Professional Wrestler
Marvel's Spider-Man NM
$0.25
1 in stockProfessor Hojo
Professor Hojo
Final Fantasy Commander NM
$0.29
1 in stockProfessor Onyx - Borderless
Professor Onyx - Borderless
Strixhaven: School of Mages NM Borderless
$12.02
3 in stockProfound Journey
Profound Journey
Dragons of Tarkir LP
$0.25
4 in stockProgenitor Exarch
Progenitor Exarch
March of the Machine LP
$0.31
4 in stockPrognostic Sphinx
Prognostic Sphinx
Theros LP
$0.25
2 in stockProjektor Inspector - Foil
Projektor Inspector - Foil
Murders at Karlov Manor · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockPromise of Bunrei
Promise of Bunrei
Commander: Innistrad: Crimson Vow NM
$0.30
1 in stockPromise of Loyalty
Promise of Loyalty
March of the Machine Commander NM
$0.38
1 in stockPromise of Power
Promise of Power
Commander 2014 NM
$0.50
11 in stockPrompto Argentum
Prompto Argentum
Final Fantasy NM
$0.25
2 in stockPrompto Argentum - Foil
Prompto Argentum - Foil
Final Fantasy · ✦ Foil NM
$0.30
1 in stockPrompto Argentum - Foil - Borderless
Prompto Argentum - Foil - Borderless
Final Fantasy · ✦ Foil NM Borderless
$0.33
1 in stockProphetic Bolt
Prophetic Bolt
Mystery Booster NM
$0.98
3 in stockProphetic Flamespeaker
Prophetic Flamespeaker
Journey into Nyx LP
$0.41
1 in stockProphetic Ravings
Prophetic Ravings
Mystery Booster NM
$0.25
14 in stock
Prosperous Innkeeper - Secret Lair Showdown (SLP)
Prosperous Innkeeper - Secret Lair Showdown (SLP)
Secret Lair Drop Series NM
$0.66
1 in stockProsthetic Injector
Prosthetic Injector
Phyrexia: All Will Be One NM
$0.25
1 in stockProtean Hulk - Retro Frame
Protean Hulk - Retro Frame
Ravnica Remastered NM Retro Frame
$7.51
1 in stockProtean Hydra
Protean Hydra
Magic 2011 LP
$4.16
1 in stockProwcatcher Specialist - Foil
Prowcatcher Specialist - Foil
Aetherdrift · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
4 in stockProwling Serpopard
Prowling Serpopard
Amonkhet LP
$3.83