The Forge Shop

The Store

14,368 items in stock across every game we carry — search anything, or drill into a game on the left.

14,368 items

1 in stock
Captain Enoch - Captain of the Guard - Hyperspace
Captain Enoch - Captain of the Guard - Hyperspace
Legends of the Force · ✦ Hyperspace NM
$1.43
17 in stockCaptain Farron - 015/298 - Uncommon
Captain Farron - 015/298 - Uncommon
Origins NM
$0.25
1 in stockCaptain Farron - 015/298 - Uncommon - Foil
Captain Farron - 015/298 - Uncommon - Foil
Origins · ✦ Foil NM
$0.27
1 in stock
Captain Hook - Captain of the Jolly Roger - 173/204 - Rare
Captain Hook - Captain of the Jolly Roger - 173/204 - Rare
The First Chapter NM
$0.59
1 in stockCaptain Howler, Sea Scourge - Borderless
Captain Howler, Sea Scourge - Borderless
Aetherdrift NM Borderless
$1.32
4 in stockCaptain Lannery Storm
Captain Lannery Storm
Ixalan LP
$0.30
1 in stockCaptain Marvel, Shooting Star
Captain Marvel, Shooting Star
Marvel Super Heroes Commander · ✦ Foil NM
$13.31
2 in stockCaptain of the Watch
Captain of the Watch
Magic 2010 NM
$0.40
1 in stockCaptain of the Watch
Captain of the Watch
Magic 2013 MP
$0.32
2 in stockCaptain Phasma - Chrome Dome
Captain Phasma - Chrome Dome
Jump to Lightspeed NM
$0.25
9 in stockCaptain Rex - Fighting For His Brothers
Captain Rex - Fighting For His Brothers
Twilight of the Republic NM
$0.25
1 in stock
Captain Rex - Fighting For His Brothers - Hyperspace
Captain Rex - Fighting For His Brothers - Hyperspace
Twilight of the Republic · ✦ Hyperspace NM
$1.16
6 in stock
Captain Rex - Lead by Example - Hyperspace
Captain Rex - Lead by Example - Hyperspace
Twilight of the Republic · ✦ Hyperspace NM
$0.68
1 in stockCaptain Sisay
Captain Sisay
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal · ✦ Foil NM Borderless
$7.99
1 in stockCaptain Sisay
Captain Sisay
Secret Lair Drop Series · ✦ Foil NM Borderless
$13.38
4 in stock
Captain Titus and The Wardens of Ultramar
Captain Titus and The Wardens of Ultramar
Warhammer 40000 SEALED
$94.00
4 in stockCaptain's Claws
Captain's Claws
Oath of the Gatewatch LP
$0.41
1 in stockCaptivating Vampire - Foil
Captivating Vampire - Foil
Magic 2011 · ✦ Foil LP
$2.59
3 in stockCaradora, Heart of Alacria
Caradora, Heart of Alacria
Aetherdrift NM
$0.27
1 in stockCaradora, Heart of Alacria - Borderless
Caradora, Heart of Alacria - Borderless
Aetherdrift NM Borderless
$0.25
2 in stockCard Sharp - 081/221 - Rare - Foil
Card Sharp - 081/221 - Rare - Foil
Spiritforged · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockCaretaker's Talent
Caretaker's Talent
Bloomburrow NM
$11.86
5 in stockCargo Ship
Cargo Ship
Final Fantasy NM
$0.27
1 in stockCargo Ship - Foil
Cargo Ship - Foil
Final Fantasy · ✦ Foil NM
$0.31
1 in stockCarmen, Cruel Skymarcher
Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher
The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander NM
$7.30
Pre-orderCarmine Blades 1
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carmine Blades 1
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCarmine Blades 2
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carmine Blades 2
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCarmine Blades 3
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carmine Blades 3
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCarmine Blades 4
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carmine Blades 4
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCarmine Blades 5
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carmine Blades 5
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
2 in stockCarnage Tyrant
Carnage Tyrant
Ixalan LP
$4.98
2 in stockCarnage, Crimson Chaos
Carnage, Crimson Chaos
Marvel's Spider-Man NM
$1.39
1 in stockCarnivorous Cultivator // Enroot
Carnivorous Cultivator // Enroot
Reality Fracture NM Extended Art
$0.83
5 in stockCarnivorous Snapvine - 149/298 - Rare - Foil
Carnivorous Snapvine - 149/298 - Rare - Foil
Origins · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockCarrion Cruiser - Foil
Carrion Cruiser - Foil
Aetherdrift · ✦ Foil MP
$0.26
62 in stockCarrion Dredger
Carrion Dredger
Unleashed NM
$0.25
Special orderCarro Armato/Semovente
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Carro Armato/Semovente
Bolt Action & WWII SEALED
$40.00
7 in stockCarrot Cake
Carrot Cake
Bloomburrow NM
$0.25
1 in stockCartel Aristocrat
Cartel Aristocrat
Ravnica Remastered NM
$0.32
Pre-orderCarthalos Skin 1
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carthalos Skin 1
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCarthalos Skin 2
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carthalos Skin 2
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCarthalos Skin 3
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carthalos Skin 3
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCarthalos Skin 4
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carthalos Skin 4
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCarthalos Skin 5
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Carthalos Skin 5
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
1 in stock
Cartilage Crush (Blue)
Cartilage Crush (Blue)
Mastery Pack: Guardian NM
$0.25
1 in stockCase of the Burning Masks - Foil
Case of the Burning Masks - Foil
Murders at Karlov Manor · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
3 in stockCase of the Crimson Pulse
Case of the Crimson Pulse
Murders at Karlov Manor NM
$0.25
8 in stockCase of the Filched Falcon
Case of the Filched Falcon
Murders at Karlov Manor NM
$0.25
1 in stockCase of the Gateway Express - Foil
Case of the Gateway Express - Foil
Murders at Karlov Manor · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
3 in stockCase of the Ransacked Lab
Case of the Ransacked Lab
Murders at Karlov Manor LP
$0.51
3 in stockCase of the Stashed Skeleton
Case of the Stashed Skeleton
Murders at Karlov Manor NM
$0.30
1 in stockCase of the Uneaten Feast
Case of the Uneaten Feast
Murders at Karlov Manor NM
$0.36
7 in stockCassian Andor - Dedicated to the Rebellion
Cassian Andor - Dedicated to the Rebellion
Spark of Rebellion NM
$0.25
3 in stockCast Down
Cast Down
Dominaria NM
$0.65
4 in stockCast Out
Cast Out
Amonkhet LP
$0.25
1 in stockCastle Doom
Castle Doom
Marvel Super Heroes NM Extended Art
$2.00
2 in stockCastle Locthwain - Foil - Extended Art
Castle Locthwain - Foil - Extended Art
Throne of Eldraine · ✦ Foil NM Extended Art
$34.41
1 in stockCastle Raptors - Foil
Castle Raptors - Foil
Time Spiral Remastered · ✦ Foil NM
$0.40
1 in stockCastle Sengir
Castle Sengir
Homelands NM
$0.28
1 in stockCastle Vantress
Castle Vantress
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate NM
$0.43