The Forge Shop

The Store

14,368 items in stock across every game we carry — search anything, or drill into a game on the left.

14,368 items

1 in stockCastle Vantress
Castle Vantress
Throne of Eldraine NM
$0.38
1 in stockCasualties of War - Extended Art
Casualties of War - Extended Art
Fallout NM Extended Art
$0.94
1 in stockCat and Mouse - Foil
Cat and Mouse - Foil
Jump to Lightspeed · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockCat Collector
Cat Collector
Foundations NM
$0.31
1 in stockCat Warriors
Cat Warriors
Legends NM
$0.47
1 in stockCataclysmic Duel
Cataclysmic Duel
Vendetta · ✦ Foil NM
$0.44
1 in stockCataclysmic Gearhulk
Cataclysmic Gearhulk
Kaladesh MP
$0.32
3 in stockCataclysmic Gearhulk
Cataclysmic Gearhulk
Kaladesh LP
$0.35
1 in stockCataclysmic Prospecting - Extended Art
Cataclysmic Prospecting - Extended Art
Outlaws of Thunder Junction Commander NM Extended Art
$0.28
2 in stockCatalyst of Aeons - 138/298 - Uncommon
Catalyst of Aeons - 138/298 - Uncommon
Origins NM
$0.28
1 in stockCatapult Master
Catapult Master
Duel Decks: Elspeth vs. Tezzeret NM
$1.63
1 in stockCatastrophe
Catastrophe
Urza's Saga NM
$3.67
1 in stockCathartic Pyre
Cathartic Pyre
Innistrad: Midnight Hunt LP
$0.30
3 in stockCathartic Pyre
Cathartic Pyre
Innistrad: Midnight Hunt NM
$0.31
1 in stockCathartic Reunion
Cathartic Reunion
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal · ✦ Foil NM
$0.31
4 in stockCathartic Reunion
Cathartic Reunion
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths NM
$0.25
1 in stockCathartic Reunion - Foil
Cathartic Reunion - Foil
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal · ✦ Foil NM
$0.31
3 in stockCathedral of War
Cathedral of War
Magic 2013 LP
$1.51
9 in stockCaught in the Crossfire
Caught in the Crossfire
Twilight of the Republic NM
$0.25
1 in stockCaught in the Crossfire - Foil
Caught in the Crossfire - Foil
Outlaws of Thunder Junction · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockCauldron Familiar
Cauldron Familiar
Jumpstart NM
$3.10
1 in stockCauldron Familiar
Cauldron Familiar
Store Championships NM Inverted
$4.35
1 in stockCauldron of Souls
Cauldron of Souls
Shadowmoor LP
$8.68
4 in stockCaustic Bronco
Caustic Bronco
Outlaws of Thunder Junction NM
$0.33
1 in stockCaustic Bronco - Foil
Caustic Bronco - Foil
Outlaws of Thunder Junction · ✦ Foil NM
$0.56
5 in stockCaustic Exhale
Caustic Exhale
Tarkir: Dragonstorm NM
$0.25
1 in stockCaustic Exhale - Foil
Caustic Exhale - Foil
Tarkir: Dragonstorm · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockCavalier of Dawn
Cavalier of Dawn
Core Set 2020 NM
$5.25
1 in stockCavalier of Flame
Cavalier of Flame
Core Set 2020 NM
$2.30
2 in stockCavalier of Gales
Cavalier of Gales
Core Set 2020 NM
$2.85
2 in stockCavalier of Thorns
Cavalier of Thorns
Core Set 2020 LP
$0.44
Special orderCavalry bases pack
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Cavalry bases pack
Historical SEALED
$17.00
Special orderCavalry of the Sun King
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Cavalry of the Sun King
Historical SEALED
$40.00
3 in stockCavendish - EB01-012 - SR - Foil
Cavendish - EB01-012 - SR - Foil
Extra Booster: Memorial Collection · ✦ Foil NM
$5.32
1 in stockCavern-Hoard Dragon
Cavern-Hoard Dragon
The Hobbit Eternal · ✦ Foil NM Borderless
$29.93
1 in stockCavern-Hoard Dragon
Cavern-Hoard Dragon
The Hobbit Eternal NM
$25.68
1 in stockCaves of Chaos Adventurer - Foil
Caves of Chaos Adventurer - Foil
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · ✦ Foil NM
$0.54
1 in stockCaves of Chaos Adventurer - Foil - Extended Art
Caves of Chaos Adventurer - Foil - Extended Art
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · ✦ Foil NM Extended Art
$0.96
26 in stock
cEDH Invitational Series — Qualifier 1 — Entry
cEDH Invitational Series — Qualifier 1 — Entry
spe-mv5hicdp SEALED
$35.00
31 in stock
cEDH Invitational Series — Qualifier 2 — Entry
cEDH Invitational Series — Qualifier 2 — Entry
spe-mv5hjp54 SEALED
$35.00
31 in stock
cEDH Invitational Series — Qualifier 3 — Entry
cEDH Invitational Series — Qualifier 3 — Entry
spe-mv5hm19a SEALED
$35.00
1 in stockCelebi - XY111
Celebi - XY111
XY Promos · ✦ Holofoil LP
$44.15
1 in stockCelestial Ancient
Celestial Ancient
Dissension LP
$0.50
1 in stockCelestial Colonnade
Celestial Colonnade
Doctor Who LP
$0.33
1 in stockCelestial Colonnade
Celestial Colonnade
Ultimate Masters NM
$0.35
1 in stockCelestial Colonnade
Celestial Colonnade
Worldwake NM
$0.72
1 in stockCelestial Dawn
Celestial Dawn
Mirage NM
$0.74
4 in stockCelestial Prism
Celestial Prism
Unlimited NM
$1.26
1 in stockCelestial Purge
Celestial Purge
Magic 2012 NM
$0.30
Pre-orderCelestine Skin 1
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Celestine Skin 1
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCelestine Skin 2
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Celestine Skin 2
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCelestine Skin 3
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Celestine Skin 3
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCelestine Skin 4
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Celestine Skin 4
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
Pre-orderCelestine Skin 5
Releases Oct 24, 2026
Celestine Skin 5
Warhammer Tone Pro NM
$6.75
1 in stockCelestine, the Living Saint
Celestine, the Living Saint
Warhammer 40,000 Commander NM
$25.03
Special orderCelt Starter Army
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Celt Starter Army
Historical SEALED
$134.10 $149.00 10% off
Special orderCeltic Warriors
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Celtic Warriors
Historical SEALED
$44.00
52 in stockCemetery Attendant - 165/298 - Common
Cemetery Attendant - 165/298 - Common
Origins NM
$0.25
1 in stockCemetery Attendant - 165/298 - Common - Foil
Cemetery Attendant - 165/298 - Common - Foil
Origins · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
4 in stockCemetery Desecrator
Cemetery Desecrator
Innistrad: Crimson Vow NM
$0.42